Exchange Ideas

Causal Capital

RMB - Risk, Markets & Banking

 

« Its just human nature | Main | The Barometer of the US Equity Market »

June 15, 2008

Its not an oil crisis, its a dollar crisis

If you want to boil a frog as the saying goes you put it into cold water and raise the temperature slowly for if you throw a cold frog into hot water it will leap out. The US dollar is such an animal and over the last few years there has been some speculation on the deprecating value of the dollar but such talk until lately seems to have been background noise. Like our boiled frog until the temperature raises too high no one notices but in the last five years the US dollar has depreciated against the Euro by 35%.

We are going to look at what has caused the US dollar to collapse, how this affects international trade and what a business can do to protect itself in another article. Before any of this and to understand how the world found itself in this mess we have to look back in history, just a touch.

`A nation taxes its own citizens, while an empire taxes other nation-states` writes Krassimir Petrov and is probably the best summation I have read on what brought us to this place today and very much inspires this article considering the state of the US dollar at present. In the Early 20th Century the US dollar was tied to gold and so the value of the dollar would be entirely pegged to that of the commodity however, after the great depression there was a spout of inflation and with an increase amount of currency in circulation the Roosevelt government was forced to decouple the dollar from gold, well nearly decouple. Some years had to pass until 1945 when the Bretton Woods agreement was engaged and other governments could impress on US reserves that the dollar be convertible to gold on demand. During the years of the Second World War the US had supported many of its allies and been insisting on gold as payment so its reserves of the commodity were bountiful, well abundant enough that conversion of commodity to currency should not have presented a problem.

What is important about all of this is that up until recently the US currency has been looked at by the rest of the world as the reserve currency of the world. It`s a perception but such a strong vista in that a convertible paper (paper for goods) has base value and the US dollar became the status quo underline on a quote in trade. If the dollar supply was kept vaguely close to the market price of gold in store this perception would have been real but during the Vietnam War the supply of the dollar volume was increased to finance the extension of US forces overseas and the currency was handed over to foreign businesses in huge volumes in exchange for imported goods. The catch here is, without the ability to buy the US currency back at the same value once it was sent off shore. In 1970 when foreign governments demanded payment of dollars in gold the link between the US dollar and gold was ``severed`` and the US would be in debt to the world, well theoretically.

So why didn`t the global community unwind at that point?

Well the argument is that in 1971 the US government made an agreement with Saudi Arabia for accepting US dollars for oil and that is a resource that the rest of the world was addicted on. When the remainder of OPEC followed by settling oil contracts in US dollars there was a reason to hold the currency and the switch from gold to oil was achieved. The currency in effect had moved from one base commodity to another and in today`s market this is a significant link and as the dollar weakens the price of oil is going to have upward pressure. There are many of those in the markets that are saying we don`t have an oil crisis, we have a dollar crisis. The market place is much more complex than this as you can obviously imagine and that the rising prices of oil are due to many factors some of which are indirectly orbiting around currency differentials and some of which are positive feedback loops.

For example, one would expect that as the price of oil raises (in USD terms) the demand for such a commodity would fall off however oil is generally ``a necessity`` rather than ``a want to have`` for the commercial world so price increases are often passed on in the value chain and become inflationary catalysts for the consumer. These inflationary measures often end up contributing to the cost of imported goods where US dollars are sold for another currency and add to the bottomless hole of the US trade deficit.

We`ll look at oil and trade deficits in detail later the big question here apart from the positive feedback loops, is; why is the dollar falling?

It is argued by some that what broke the dollar away from gold to oil the first time is perhaps the same cause that has driven its deflation this time, war. Instead of Vietnam in this case it is Iraq.

The irony in it all is that Saddam Hussein demanded Euro as a settlement currency for his oil and that a war with Iraq stood to free Iraq from his grip, possibly a good thing in hindsight; but, it also stood to protect the sovereignty of the US dollar even though engaging such an act might actually put the very currency at risk.

To be concise then if this is the case, the underlying problem with the dollar lies with the large federal budget deficit and the huge growing trade deficit.

Later on we are going to look at the implications of a weak US dollar on the global economy and why the dollar is struggling to recover.

Posted by CausalEvents at June 15, 2008 02:37 AM

Comments

Martin, Very good analysis.

The question for risk managers is what else apart from interest rates, and commodities like oil and food(?), will the falling dollar impact? How about coal, then uranium?

Posted by: Pat Mc Connell at June 16, 2008 03:18 AM

Hi Martin. Interesting. Looking at the economic cycles aren't we heading for a general recession in the west at the east grows and so does their dependency on oil and other commodities as their consumer power comes into their own.
Longer term with all these other complex factors, in your opinion do you believe the dollar will recover within the next 10-15 years or do you believe this trend will continue. (Ive invested in Real Estate in US so intent to keep investing but not holding US dollars in bank accounts) Any insights would be interesting. Amanda UK investor, London (FR)

Posted by: Amanda at June 16, 2008 09:48 PM

A good analysis. Among the many factors or risk, dollar value is also one of the major player in the risk management.

Thanks Martin.

Posted by: Shai at June 21, 2008 03:36 AM

A simple OLS regression of daily WTI spot prices against the daily USD/EUR exchange rate for the last year yields a very high R-Squared (about 86%). About $25 of the $70 or so run-up in oil prices over the past year has been the result of the decrease in the value of the dollar, as the price of oil in Euros has also gone up pretty dramatically. The most obvious explanation for the deline in the dollar, however, has nothing to do with the war in Iraq. The dollar has lost so much value over the past year because the Fed has been supplying an enormous amount of liquidity to the market to deal with the dramatic decrease in the value of residential real estate in the U.S. This is a temporary adjustment that is already working its way through a basically very strong U.S. economy.

Posted by: John at June 21, 2008 06:02 AM

The analysis is higly refreshing. The author deserves compliments for putting the right perspective. If this analysis is accepted by G-8 the solution to dollar(oil)- led global inflation could be in sight earlier than predicted in the prediction markets.

Posted by: Yerram Raju at June 28, 2008 02:06 PM

The article hits at one of the core factors beind the oil crises. The details of the market interactions actually resulting in the prices we are now seeing, I think, is a little more complex.

Posted by: Kweku at July 2, 2008 05:20 AM

Missing a few commas and periods here and there; but, a very refreshing read. Thanks.

Posted by: Mwewa at July 15, 2008 02:57 AM

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)